Abstract: In recent seasons, Major League Baseball (MLB) has introduced notable changes to strike zone officiating. In 2025, MLB changed the buffer used to evaluate umpires from two inches outside the strike zone to three-quarters of an inch on each side of the strike zone. Then in 2026, MLB introduced the Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) challenge system, enabling players to challenge the umpire's call. Evaluating how these rule changes alter umpire behavior requires separating the effect of the rule changes from any underlying temporal confounding in umpire aging and trajectory dynamics. In this work, we fit Bayesian Additive Regression Tree (BART) and Gaussian Process (GP) models to capture the spatial and temporal variation in each umpire's called strike probabilities between 2009 and 2024. We then use these models to forecast each umpire's counterfactual called strike probabilities that would be observed had the new buffer and ABS systems not been implemented. Our modeling allows us to evaluate whether MLB's rule changes have reduced umpire-to-umpire variability and produced more homogeneous called-strike behavior. This study illustrates the challenging nuances of causal inference, resulting in a framework for evaluating rule changes when nonlinear spatial dynamics and longitudinal confounding throw a curveball at modern sports analytics. This is based on joint work with Sameer Deshpande and Jared Fisher.
Ron Yurko is an
Assistant Teaching Professor in the Department of Statistics
& Data Science at Carnegie Mellon University and the
Director of the Carnegie Mellon Sports Analytics Center (CMSAC).
His research focuses on developing statistical methods at the
interface of inference and machine learning, with applications
in sports analytics and natural language processing. Under his
leadership, CMSAC drives high-impact industry partnerships,
including recent collaborations with the NFL Draft and the
Heisman Hopefuls platform. His work and commentary have been
featured in major outlets such as The Athletic, ESPN,
CBS, and NBC. He has industry experience in finance and
professional sports, and holds bachelor's, master's, and PhD
degrees in Statistics from Carnegie Mellon.
Abstract and biography forthcoming.